The Fantasy of Restoration: A Polemic Against Rupert Lowe

A graffiti-style poster on a textured off-white, slightly stained wall reads in bold red hand-painted letters: “BRITAIN DOESN’T NEED RESTORING IT NEEDS REBUILDING — FROM THE GROUND UP, BY AND FOR THE MANY.” The paint appears uneven and dripping in places
MP Rupert Lowe peddles a fantasy of lost greatness to mask the failures of those who’ve ruled and ruined this country. The problem isn’t immigration or identity. It’s inequality, privatisation, and a political class that sold off the future for short-term profit. You want courage? Try telling the truth about power.

It takes a certain kind of gall to survey a broken country ( the underfunded schools, unaffordable homes, food banks in every postcode) and declare that the real problem is not enough nationalism. MP Rupert Lowe’s puffed-up nostalgia reads less like a call to action and more like a eulogy for an imaginary country that never really existed.

Let’s be clear: Britain did not “build a vast civilisation.” It built an empire. Through conquest, extraction, slavery, and violence. You can dress it up with talk of duty and decency, but there’s no moral high ground in the plunder of Bengal or the famines engineered by imperial policy. “We abolished slavery,” Lowe crows, omitting that Britain was also one of the chief architects of the slave economy, and that the compensation went not to the enslaved but to the slaveowners. A little historical humility wouldn’t go amiss.

The idea that immigration didn’t play a role in Britain’s so-called greatness is laughable. The NHS, the postwar rebuild, the cultural and scientific richness of modern Britain. None of it exists without migrants. People from the Caribbean, South Asia, Ireland, and beyond helped make Britain liveable after the war. To erase them from the story is not just bad history, it’s political cowardice.

This isn’t about pride. It’s about power. Lowe’s “restoration” fantasy is a cover for a reactionary programme: border crackdowns, culture war posturing, and authoritarian drift dressed up in the language of decency and resolve. But there’s no decency in scapegoating the vulnerable, no courage in rewriting history to suit your politics. If anything is being “diluted,” it’s the truth.

What we are watching is not national decline. This is the ongoing failure of the British dominant class. The country wasn’t brought low by refugees or woke teachers, but by deregulated finance, asset-stripping privatisation, and a political elite that hollowed out public life while enriching itself. If Rupert Lowe wants to know why things feel like they are “slipping through our fingers,” he should look at the landlords, hedge funds, and newspaper barons. Certainly not the kids learning English as a second language in an underfunded classroom.

This is not restoration. It is retreat. A retreat into myth, into grievance, into the fog of post-imperial melancholy. The real fight is not to reclaim a fantasy of Britain past, but to build a future where decency isn’t a slogan but a lived condition: housing as a right, health as a public good, borders that don’t kill, history that tells the truth.

You want courage? Try telling the truth about power. Try standing with the people actually trying to make Britain liveable. The nurses, renters’ unions, climate activists, and teachers. Rather than flogging a broken nostalgia to those desperate for someone to blame.

Britain doesn’t need restoring. It needs rebuilding from the ground up, by and for the many.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share the Post:

Latest Posts

Britain

Jenrick’s Gutter Politics

Jenrick’s “medieval attitudes” line isn’t about protecting women — it’s about importing the far right’s script into the Tory mainstream. From Powell to Farage, the cast has changed but the grammar is the same: the outsider as danger, the nation as victim, the politician as saviour.

Read More »
The Gaza Catastrophe cover Cover of Gilbert Achcar’s book "The Gaza Catastrophe: The Genocide in World-Historical Perspective". A young man carries a child through a devastated landscape, with other displaced Palestinians walking behind him and a column of smoke rising in the background.
Book Review

The Catastrophe Was the Point: Gilbert Achcar’s Dialectic of Gaza

Gilbert Achcar’s The Gaza Catastrophe is not a plea for sympathy. It is a political weapon. Written in the midst of genocide, it strips away the euphemisms, the diplomatic theatre, and the moral fog. This war, he argues, is a settler-colonial project. Accelerated to its most brutal form, with the full backing of the Western powers who claim to uphold human rights. Achcar names the system, maps its historical scaffolding, and indicts not only Israel but the global order that enables it. This is not a book of mourning. It is a call to act.

Read More »